Can't we all disagree one day and then the next unite on what we have overwhelmingly in common? I hold nothing against you , and it's important for shiachat to To the prophet saying ya ali.
Prophet muhammad (saww) used to say ya ali. You people want to. The majority of its practitioners are shia and sufi.
[citation needed] the vocative yā when used with allāh is used to call upon god for help. During the mourning of muharram, spontaneous slogans of ya hussain, ya ali. Why do shias say ya ali?
یاعلی “o ali”) is an arabic phrase used by muslims to invoke the memory or intervention of ali ibn abu talib. Shia muslims use this phrase in an act called tawassul (intercession). They call upon ali believing that the intercession of ali will allow their prayer to be granted.
Why do shia say ya ali? یاعلی “o ali”) is an arabic phrase used by muslims to invoke the memory or intervention of ali ibn abu talib. Shia muslims use this phrase in an act called tawassul (intercession).
They call upon ali believing that the intercession of ali will allow their prayer to be granted. It was umar ibn abdil aziz who canceled this order after more than half a century. Some historians even believe that the umayyah descendants themselves killed (poisoned) umar ibn abdil aziz, because he changed their sunnah, one of which was cursing ali.
So when we say ya ali madad, in no way do we belittle the prophet pbuh. Even assuming the bukhari narrations are accepted by the shia (which are not), and even assuming asking a dead person for help is shirk (based on those hadith), asking help from martyrs, which are clearly described as alive in. Why do shia muslims say ya ali madad (o ali help) ?
And shia people should pray to the one whom ali prayed to. Ali didnt pray to himself…. Allah is god the only god and the only one who will grant anyones prayers…
